A March 5th midnight show, 3 screens 2 sold out, surrounded by comic book fans from my local comic shop, I saw The Watchmen. So what did I think of it. Quite simply I liked it. It was good. If I had to pinpoint one problem the movie had was its runtime. Clocking in at 165 minutes, it is just too short to completely capture the soul of the graphic novel. It novel is very dense. An average comic book will take me between 10-15 minutes to read, an issue of The Watchmen (the graphic novel is a collection of the 12 issue mini-series) can take me closer to 20-25 minutes, just because there is so much information, not only in the words but in the art as well. Of course some things were cut or truncated for the adaptation, which I expected, but there was only so much you could omit. It is the volume of content combined with the runtime that makes a good portion of the film is rushed, robbing certain scenes of their emotional impact and character development. However, I will add that the changes made to the big climax of the movie did not lessen the impact of the events and the message of the story, making me very happy.
One place where the movie excels is the acting on the part of Jackie Earle Haley was spot on. He brought is character of Rorschach to life, and I challenge anyone to read (or re-read) the graphic novel and not have Rorschach sound like he did in the movie. I know that as I finish up my fourth re-read I have that voice in my head. Another outstanding performance came from Patrick Wilson’s Dan Dreiberg, Nite Owl II. When I do read The Watchmen, this is how I picture Dan Dreiberg. Billy Crudup as Dr. Manhattan (he actually did act the part, he was replaced in post-production just like Andy Serkis was in the Lord of the Rings movies), was cold, withdrawn and a bit scary, so he also did a good job. There were some issues with the CGI. I did read a review in which did confirm one of my thought while watching it, that the mouth movements were sometimes iffy. Malin Akerman definitely looked the part of Laurie Juspeczyk (she was Laurie Jupiter in the movie, but in the novel she makes it a point to correct people so, so will I), but there were times her performance was stiff.
Sadly, in the end the legendary creator Alan Moore, was probably right, it is “unfilmable”. However, I do not think it is because of the material in the novel, but that Hollywood won’t give it the time it needs to tell the story. It needs at least 2 3hour movies, or even better a 12 episode mini-series on HBO or Showtime to come close to being able to tell the story the right way.
I could go into more detail as to where I felt the movie went south or excelled, and I may later on, but I do not want to so until more people have a chance to see it. What I will say is that in the graphic novel there is a comic within the comic which Zack Snyder has turned into an animated direct to DVD feature called “Tales of the Black Freighter” (out on March 24th), and the reports are that Warner Brothers has Snyder cut down the original runtime of the movie to under 3 hours. I am hopeful that the eventual extended directors cut (which will include the Black Freighter cut within the movie) will be better than the theatrical release and become the standard (just like the Blade Runner Director’s Cut), but that doesn’t mean you should wait for it. Go out and see The Watchmen, hell I am even going to see it again, and by all means if you haven’t read the graphic novel, go and read it.